Hubba Hubba NX vs Elixir 2 Tent Comparison

MSR elixir 2 tent

To most outward appearances, these tents look identical. The latest models both sport the same colours and, without the writing on the tents, would be indistinguishable at first sight. However, get close to these tents when pitched or pick up the packed bags and you will notice a few differences:

The Weight

The tents are identical in size but markedly different in weight. The Hubba Hubba NX comes in at 1.72 kg (3 lbs 13 oz)  and the Elixir 2 at ‎2.64 kg (5 lbs 13 oz), a noticeable difference of 820 grams. For all the ultralight packers out there, this may tip the balance in favour of the Hubba Hubba. But the weight is also a double-edged sword: being of identical size, the weight difference is in the pole construction and the fabric of the materials used to construct the fly and inner. Ignoring the poles for a minute, that means that the Hubba Hubba NX has saved a huge amount of weight by using thinner fabric. Thinner fabric of similar materials is less durable and the Hubba Hubba’s rainfly has some pretty thin fabric: 20D ripstop nylon to the Elixir’s 68D ripstop polyester. The D stands for denier and is a measure of how densely the material has been threaded; higher values will mean higher durability.

A similar picture on the inner material: 20D ripstop nylon on the Hubba Hubba NX to the 40D ripstop nylon on the Elixir 2. This isn’t a technicality either; a quick sweep of the web will yield lots of threads with people complaining about the thinness and poor durability of the latest iteration of the Hubba Hubba NX. It was mainly for this reason that we went with the Elixir 2. We are world bike tourers and durability is the last thing we want to be worrying about. If our tent fabric comes apart in the middle of nowhere after just a year of constant use, it is simply not fit for purpose. Not to mention, the 820 gram savings don’t just come at a cost of durability, it will dent your bank account as well.

Price

We are very much budget travellers. We successfully cycled in Europe without money for over 6 weeks and before that attempted to make every penny go a long way. At 23 years old, I didn’t have a long time to save up money (at 20, Katie had even less!), so price comes into every purchasing decision. In some ways this is great; it forces us to really evaluate the necessity of every purchase and we do a lot of research when we buy anything, especially so when it is something as vital to our comfort and survival as a tent.

In this case, it kind of ended up being a no-brainer, especially after the consideration of durability was taken into account. The Hubba Hubba NX has an RRP of $400 to the Elixir 2’s $250, a 60% price increase which could only be justified by the considerable weight savings and decrease in pack size. That wasn’t justification enough for us and we both agreed that the Elixir 2 would suit us well.

[table “1” not found /]

Our Verdict

We have used and reviewed the MSR Elixir 2 extensively on our travels. We haven’t had our hands on the Hubba Hubba NX for anywhere near the same amount of time, so it would be unfair to make comment on the practicality and durability of the tent ourselves. However, given that the tents are so incredibly similar and differ only in fabric and pole construction, we feel confident making a comparison based solely on the biggest differences between these two tents: the weight and the price.

If weight is an absolutely serious concern for you, and saving some pack size would really make a difference to your trip, then the Hubba Hubba NX should be your tent of choice. If you, like us, are budget conscious and don’t mind lugging around an extra 800 grams with the added benefit of increased durability, the decision to go for the Elixir 2 should be easy enough.

9 thoughts on “Hubba Hubba NX vs Elixir 2 Tent Comparison

  • 21st December 2016 at 6:47 pm
    Permalink

    We were also torn between the two and also chose the Elixir 2, but we based our decision on the poles’ pivot/attachment point: metal (E2) vs. plastic (Hubba Hubba). The plastic pole coupling on the Hubba Hubba seemed like a natural failure poin

    Reply
    • 23rd December 2016 at 8:20 pm
      Permalink

      Interesting stuff Denyse. Would be interested to hear from people using the Hubba Hubba about their experience with this!

      Reply
  • 22nd December 2016 at 5:04 pm
    Permalink

    Have been using the Elixir 2 for most of my trips over the last year. Great tent, I wanted the extra durability for bikebacking, and it has shown. Be careful when putting the poles together, I have had one problem with the aluminum cracking where they join.

    Reply
    • 23rd December 2016 at 8:21 pm
      Permalink

      We have noticed occasionally too that the poles don’t always snap completely into place. I’m sure that weakens the poles when bent and could cause something similar. Always worth a double check before bending the poles into place.

      Reply
    • 23rd December 2016 at 8:17 pm
      Permalink

      Super value indeed! There are only a couple of other tents which compare for value, but neither are available in the UK/EU.

      Reply
  • 29th December 2016 at 2:15 am
    Permalink

    We have been using Hubba Hubba NX pretty much none-stop for about 8 months now. Well, we had one another tent before made by Vango and had this tent for about 6 years plus used it on our tour every day for about 9 months. The advantages of Hubba Hubba NX are pretty obvious it’s very light weight, free standing and great for hotter climates with good air circulation. Now on the another hand after 8 months we can say that the quality of this product compared to our previous Vango tent is pretty poor. The seams are pretty much gone and the outer fabric shows sporadically very tiny holes. Tent is also not much rain proof as we would hoped. In the heavy rain the outer shell is completely wet inside and only because of the sheet angle it doesn’t rain inside. In summary we don’t think that the tent quality matches its price. At this point we’re pretty disappointed with the low quality of MSR.

    Reply
    • 29th December 2016 at 5:46 pm
      Permalink

      Hi Oli, we are also a little disappointed with the ‘rainproofness’ of our Elixir 2. We have had some nasty storms here in Peru where the inside of the outer has also become soaking wet. It is interesting to hear first-hand about the durability of the Hubba Hubba NX. We will be using the Elixir 2 for many months to come and hope that it will live up to our expectations in the long run.

      It seems to be that the obsession with ultralight equipment is leading tent manufaturers to use thinner and thinner materials at the cost of durability. Most people only use their tents a handful of times each year and don’t see the kind of wear-and-tear that we, as nomadic travellers, do. It’s just something we have to bear in mind when making purchases; lighter is definitely not always better when it comes to equipment we hope will last for many years.

      Reply
  • 29th March 2017 at 6:17 pm
    Permalink

    Thanks for the great review here, also the comments are great. I am in the process of deciding on a tent for backpacking, I was looking between the Vango Tempest and Nova but the 300 series as some trips I will have my son with me and I don’t think the 200 would be big enough. When looking at the MSR tents the weight comes down a fair bit, ok the Hubba Hubba NX 2 is using budget right now, but the Elixir 2 is good and what I read above it would serve me well. I would just like to see on in the flesh now, I have seen the Vango tents in the display are of Go Outdoors here in the UK, so need to track down someone local with these tents on display.

    Thanks.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *